Enjoy Delicious Homemade Pies and Comfort Food at the Potbelly Restaurant in Red Feather Lakes

Welcome to Potbelly Restaurant

Nestled at 24340 Red Feather Lakes Rd, Potbelly Restaurant invites you into a world of comfort and flavor. Whether you’re craving hearty steak tips, homemade pies or their famous smothered green chili burrito, this Red Feather Lakes time-honored dining destination boasts an inviting atmosphere that is perfect for gatherings with friends and family.

Delicious Offerings and Comfortable Dining Experience

Potbelly is terrific for offering a variety of choices, including fantastic salads (with homemade dressings) and delicious soups and sandwiches. The Friday fish fry is a local favorite, and for those looking for something different, the Thursday chef’s special feature crave-worthy comfort foods that really hit the spot. Don’t forget to try the famous homemade pies—the perfect sweet end to your meal!

Partially eaten pecan pie on wooden table at the Potbelly Restaurant in Red Feather Lakes, Colorado
Potbelly Restaurant Homemade Pecan Pie – Available Seasonally!

Cozy Ambiance and Relaxation

One of the best parts about Potbelly is the cozy fireplaces that create a warm and welcoming vibe. As you relax in their comfortable dine-in seating, take the time to watch the hummingbirds visit feeders hung near the windows, adding a touch of nature to your dining experience. And for those who enjoy a social atmosphere, the full bar is well-stocked with craft beers on tap, cider and mixed drinks to complement your meals or shareable appetizers.

Visit the Potbelly Restaurant and enjoy all that they have to offer. From the delicious menu to a stunningly cozy ambiance, a meal at the Potbelly will make your visit memorable!

Visit them on Facebook Check out Google Reviews!

Potbelly Restaurant, Red Feather Lakes CO
Potbelly Restaurant, Red Feather Lakes CO

Faye & Chris
Author: Faye & Chris

We're Faye and Chris, and we live up here in the Rocky Mountains of Larimer County. Everything on this site comes from actually being out in it — Chris is the driver, and Faye is the writer/photographer. Between us we built the Larimer Wilds apps so other people can find this wild mountain country too. We're not a tourism board and nobody pays us to say any of this. We're two people who love, hike, bike and ride Northwest Larimer County and would rather help you do it right than watch you learn it the hard way.

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top